Arguments from Motivated Skepticism
Argument from Motivated Skepticism Contents Introduction A Motivating Example: Radiometric Dating and the Age of the Earth Reductio Through Epistemic Consequences The Argument from Motivated Skepticism (AMS) Hidden Assumptions of the Argument from Motivated Skepticism Critical Questions for the Argument from Motivated Skepticism Applying the Argument from Motivated Skepticism Why the Argument from Motivated Skepticism Is Persuasive Epistemic Holism and the Limits of Selective Skepticism Conclusion Introduction Skepticism occupies a central place in rational inquiry. Scientific progress depends upon questioning assumptions, testing accepted theories, and remaining open to revision in light of new evidence. Likewise, philosophy has long regarded skepticism as an indispensable tool for exposing weak arguments and unjustified beliefs. To be skeptical is not merely permissible; it i...